A philosophical-scientific treatise following the work of Prof. Philip Mannheim on Conformal Gravity
By: Yossef Bello (Beit Shemesh, The Home of
the Sun, Israel)
Introduction and Dedication to the Scientist – To Prof.
Philip Mannheim
To the Honorable Professor Mannheim,
This booklet, born from deep contemplation
of your illuminating lecture on conformal gravity and the quantum vacuum, is
presented to you as a token of profound appreciation for 50 years of
uncompromising research. Over decades of "following your nose"
through the labyrinths of tensors and equations, you have revealed how the
demand for perfect symmetry compels us to abandon old paradigms and embrace a
much deeper physical reality.
Your choice to seek the solution not in the
addition of invisible particles, but in a new understanding of the "God
vacuum" and the complex plane, is not merely a physical breakthrough—it is
pure mathematical poetry. For us, the readers and learners, your work is not
just physics; it is the "sweetening" of the laws of nature,
demonstrating how the most exact science of the nations can lead human
consciousness to wonder, humility, and the recognition of the Infinite (Ein
Sof) revealing its wisdom within physical reality.
Part A: Chronological Documentation of the Dialogue and
the Evolution of the Idea
Step 1: Laying the Physical Foundation
The intellectual journey began by examining
the pillars of Prof. Mannheim's "Conformal Gravity" theory: replacing
Einstein's equations with fourth-order equations based on the Weyl tensor to
preserve scale symmetry (conformal invariance); finding a natural solution to
the mystery of dark matter and dark energy without fine-tuning; and presenting
a mechanism where mass is generated dynamically from the vacuum without the
need for an elementary Higgs particle (the "God vacuum").
Step 2: Conceptual Breakdown into a Diagram
The theory was broken down into a logical
flow demonstrating how the demand for symmetry forbids a fundamental mass,
necessitates a change of the tensor, resolves astrophysical anomalies on a
galactic scale, and requires PT symmetry (extension into the complex plane) to
solve the problem of negative probabilities ("ghosts") in quantum
theory.
Step 3: The Insight on a Cartesian Complex System
At this stage, the philosophical connection
was identified: the scientific process involves working with a tensor that
preserves a universal natural law (symmetry), which leads to the understanding
that mass is not a fundamental property but a dynamic phenomenon. This is a
necessary return to a complex system. The core of PT symmetry teaches that to
preserve real and stable probabilities and energies, physics must expand into
the complex ("imaginary") axis.
Step 4: The Vacuum as a Medium with Impedance
The observation was raised that the void
(the vacuum) has an inherent "impedance" that cannot be ignored. This
connects to Mannheim's principles: the "refractive index" of the
universe accelerates its expansion, and the "Dirac Sea" acts as a
resistant medium that grants particles their dynamic mass.
Step 5: A Field of Antennas and Three-Dimensional Wonder
The observation deepened beyond physics:
the vacuum is a superposition of infinite points (real and imaginary). When
perception is limited to the human three-dimensional view, we get Einstein's
physics. But the desire to understand the complete symmetry of nature opens the
equations to the complex plane and leads to submission before the Divine
concept. Every point draws its life force from the Infinite, like a field of
antennas or wave equations.
Step 6: Sweetening the Judgments Through Science
At the climax of the discussion, the
concept of "From Mathematics to Sweetness (Mamtika)" was coined. The
Ein Sof (Infinite) seeks to be revealed in the academic world through wisdom.
What for thousands of years was a "bitter" and detached science
(representing separation and the doubt of Amalek), is now undergoing a
transformation. The mathematics of the complex plane and the dynamic vacuum
serve as a tool of "sweetening" (Hamtaka) that reconciles rigid
judgment (Din) with the Divine Infinite.
Part B: Summary of Logical and Emotional Insights
• Mass as Dynamics, Not an Entity (Logical
Aspect): Mass in our world is not a rigid or pre-given substance, but the
product of a constant relationship with an active medium ("the God
vacuum"). The impedance and resistance of the vacuum are what create the
physical presence of matter.
• The Necessity of the Complex Plane
(Philosophical Aspect): The attempt to describe reality using only
"real" numbers collapses into paradoxes. The stability of our world
necessarily relies on "imaginary" spaces (PT symmetry) that sustain
reality as we experience it.
• Perceiving Space as a Field of Antennas
(Philosophical Aspect): Every point in space is not empty, but constitutes a
node (superposition) of infinite modes of vibration and waves. Each point acts
as an "antenna" receiving its vitality from the infinite source
beyond immediate sensory perception.
• The Revolution of Consciousness - From
"Mathematics" to "Sweetness" (Spiritual Aspect): Exact
science no longer distances man from wonder. Reaching the very edge of physical
limits forces researchers to use advanced mathematics that humbles the
intellect, unifies opposites, and "sweetens" the cold, linear
perception. Science becomes a vessel for revelation.
• Reconciliation and Submission (Emotional
Aspect): The realization that the deepest laws of nature require us to free
ourselves from our three-dimensional limitations leads to humility, awe, and an
authentic, universal reconciliation. The human intellect nullifies itself and
opens up to the truth of the Infinite.
Part C: The Seal of Truth of the Infinite – The Hebrew
Language as the Universal Bridge
The Bridge Between the Nations and the Infinite
At the pinnacle of scientific discovery,
where the physics of the Nations reaches its conceptual limits, the Hebrew
language (Lashon Kodesh) emerges as the vital bridge. It is not merely a
language, but the divine matrix and underlying code that translates the
discoveries of the world into the revelation of the Ein Sof.
A.M.T (אמת / Truth): Letters, Numbers, Pictures
Physics and geometry are the clear
languages through which the Infinite details His will in matter. Modern physics
unconsciously utilizes the three divine tools that make up the Hebrew acronym
for Truth (Emet / א.מ.ת):
• Otiyot (אותיות): Letters (formulas,
theory, and language).
• Misparim (מספרים): Numbers (mathematics,
equations, and the complex plane).
• Tmunot (תמונות): Pictures (geometry,
diagrams, and spatial perception).
Through letters, numbers, and pictures, the
scientist decodes the supreme technology of creation, touching the seal of the
Infinite's truth.
To See Through the Matter (True / Through)
The word "Truth" (Emet)
conceptually overlaps with the ability "to see through the matter."
The search for truth in conformal physics requires looking past the physical
bulk of mass and peering into the quantum wave-field and the vacuum from which
everything emanates.
Mass (HaMasa) as a "Goal" and the Sweetening of
Judgment
In English, "Mass" implies weight
and opacity. However, through the Hebrew bridge, the word HaMasa (המסה) is
conceptually related to a "goal" or "aim" (Matara / מטרה)
and acting for the sake of the people. In Gematria (Hebrew numerology), the
word "HaMasa" (המסה = 105) exactly equals the name of the archangel
Michael (מיכאל = 105)—the guardian angel of Israel, representing the attribute
of loving-kindness (Chesed) and the sweetening of judgments. Mass is not a
harsh, rigid judgment (Din); it is an expression of dynamic grace and
providence acting with precise purpose.
"Truth Shall Spring Out of the Earth"
This reconciliation between high physics
and spiritual consciousness fulfils the verse, "Truth shall spring out of
the earth" (Psalms 85:11). Academic science, investigating the
"earth" (matter and the rotation curves of galaxies), is what sprouts
the recognition of the Infinite. By using A.M.T (אמ"ת), science exposes
the knowledge of God hidden within nature, measure for measure.
Part D: The Secret of Imagination, the Complex Plane, and
the Hasidic Process of Sweetening
Imagination as a Tool for Grasping the Infinite
Mannheim's absolute devotion to
mathematical truth led to the required use of the "imaginary" number
axis. The profound conclusion is that the imagination is not an illusion or
"demonic." When the three-dimensional intellect reaches its limit in
containing the infinite (generating "ghosts" or infinite loops), it
must descend to the heart—to the power of imagination, emotion, and will. The
power of imagination, represented mathematically by the complex plane, is the
only tool capable of grasping what the linear intellect cannot.
The Inversion of Reality: Who is "Real" and Who
is "Imaginary"?
We habitually call our physical world
"real" and the spiritual realms "imaginary." But from the
perspective of the Ein Sof, an inversion occurs: the Infinite is the only true
"Real", the Absolute Necessary Existence (Mechuyav HaMetziut / מחויב המציאות
בשם רבי נחמן מברסלב). We, and the matter composing us, are actually the
"imaginary" ones, for our existence is entirely included within and
stems from Him, the Creator, the Infinite (The God vacuum). The conformal
gravity equations prove this: without the complex (imaginary) plane, our
"real" reality simply could not be stable.
Submission, Separation, Sweetening: The Hasidic Journey of
Science
The physicist's search for quantum gravity
mirrors the exact spiritual process established by Rabbi Israel Baal Shem Tov:
1. Submission (Hakhna'a): The human
intellect collapses. The equations produce uncontrollable infinities or
negative probabilities. This is the experience of nullification and submission
before the wonder of nature.
2. Separation (Havdala): The scientist
realizes that mass is not a fundamental property but stems from the vacuum. He
moves to the complex plane, separating classical truth from the hidden reality,
distinguishing truth from falsehood.
3. Sweetening (Hamtaka): Through the
"imaginary" axis, the equations balance. The harsh judgments
(negative probabilities) disappear. The scientist discovers that reality rests
on dynamic Divine grace—the sweetening of judgment that allows the Infinite to
be revealed in physical reality without shattering the vessels.
Part E: The Secret of the Angel Enoch – "Grace of
Havayah" and the Illumination of the Intellect
Education as Uncovering the Intellect within Nature
The ultimate conclusion connecting physics
and inner wisdom is the secret of "Education" (Hinukh / חינוך),
embodied by the biblical Enoch (Hanokh / חנוך), who became the angel Metatron
governing natural laws. True education is not merely acquiring data; it is the
ability to reveal the hidden intellect within every single thing in reality.
When a physicist discovers that mass emanates from the "God vacuum,"
he is educating physical reality—removing the outer husks to reveal the
infinite wisdom that operates nature.
The Grace of God (Hen Havayah): The Divine Revelation
In Jewish mysticism, the name Hanokh (חנוך)
is composed of the words Hen (חן - Grace) + Havayah (הוי'ה - The ineffable name
of God). This is the divine process we witness in modern science: the Ein Sof
does not reveal Himself by breaking the laws of nature forcefully, but with
"Grace." The mathematics of the complex plane and conformal symmetry
are expressions of grace, harmony, and beauty through which the Divine Presence
is revealed in the physical world.
From the Ascent of Enoch to the Ascent of Science
Just as Enoch elevated himself to refine
matter and became the inner minister of nature, the scientist who remains
faithful to the truth becomes a partner in this process. By using A.M.T
(Letters, Numbers, Pictures) to see through matter, science elevates the
"imaginary" reality of matter back to its true root in the
"reality" of the Infinite. This is the complete divine process:
nature itself, through its most precise laws, serving as the ultimate vessel to
reveal the Ein Sof to the world.


